Telephone
02-77093611
Line
@fdlaw
address
17th Floor, No. 180, Section 2, Dunhua South Road, Da'an District, Taipei City
Last updated: August 15, 2025｜Author:Lawyer Li Yusheng(Fidelity Law's host lawyer/guest legal commentator on political commentary programs)
⚠️ Urgent Tips:If you are under investigation under the Corruption Ordinance, please take immediate action:
- Consult a lawyer before refusing an interrogation call (avoid the "witness-turned-defendant" trap)
- Collecting evidence of "public funds for public use" (core elements of the large reservoir theory)
- 24-hour lawyer hotline:02-77093611(Call encryption ensures privacy)
This article focuses on navigation
- What is the Great Reservoir Theory? The Supreme Court's ruling says
- Three Essential Elements for Applying the Crime of Corruption (Practical Checklist for Lawyers)
- 6 Methods the Prosecutor Uses to "Break the Big Reservoir" | Analysis of Countermeasures
- Successful Case: How Lawyer Li Used the Large Reservoir Theory to Help Clients Obtain Not Guilty
- Golden Action List for 72 Hours After Being Searched
1. What is the "Great Reservoir Theory"? The Supreme Court defines it this way.
When a civil servant is accused"Abuse of office to accept improper benefits"(Article 5, Paragraph 1, Clause 3 of the Anti-Corruption Ordinance), the Big Water Tank Theory is the most critical innocence defense strategy, and its legal basis is derived from:
「Supreme Court Judgment No. 4598, 2011"Explicitly stated:
"Civil servants use the public funds they handle for official expenses.If the overall balance of paymentsSince there is no subjective intention to enrich oneself, it does not constitute the crime of embezzlement."
Vernacular analysis:
Just like pouring money into a big reservoir, as long as:
- All funds are used forOfficial business-related purposes
- personalNo illegal benefits were actually obtained
- Expenditure items and positionsReasonable relevance
Even if there are procedural flaws (e.g., bidding is not conducted strictly in accordance with the Procurement Law), it may still be possible to argue that the crime of corruption has not been committed.
II. Three Key Requirements for Applying the Large Reservoir Theory (Lawyer's Practical Checklist)
according toSupreme Court Judgment No. 3567, 2018When the court examines the large reservoir theory, it will strictly examine:
| Requirements | Prosecutor's focus | Lawyer Defense Strategies |
|---|---|---|
| Clarity of public funds for public use | Allegations of funds going to unknown destinations or being mixed into private accounts | Submit receipts and verification documents (written explanation of procedural defects needs to be corrected) |
| Overall balance of payments | Compare the difference between original budget and actual expenditure | Prepare a "Fund Flow Comparison Table" and attach it to the file (an accountant's report will be more helpful) |
| Job relevance | Advocate that "dinners and gifts" are personal social interactions | ReferencesThe Executive Yuan promulgates the "Code of Ethics for Civil Servants' Integrity"Article 7 Standards of Official Etiquette |
❗ Fatal mistakes in practice:
Many parties mistakenly believe that "having a receipt can exempt them from liability", butSupreme Court Judgment No. 1234, 2011Point out:
"If the expenses are clearly unreasonable (e.g., high meal expenses unrelated to job duties), they may still be considered as inflated claims."
👉 It is recommended to immediately practice with your lawyer the "10 major loopholes that the prosecutor may question":02-77093611
III. Six Methods the Prosecutor Uses to Debunk the "Big Reservoir Theory" | Lawyers' Countermeasures
During investigations, prosecutors typically employ the following tactics, and our corresponding litigation strategies include:
Method 1: Tracking the gap in the "fund lock-up period"
The prosecution will compare:
Payment collection time(eg: project acceptance date) andSpending timeIs there a "significant delay"?
- 📌 Lawyer's counterattack:Claiming the nature of "advance payment/advance payment", citingHigh Court Judgment No. 56, 2016"Delayed payment of public funds is not necessarily illegal"
Tactic 2: Questioning the legitimacy of "alternative funding sources"
When a party claims that "the funds in Case A were used to pay for Case B," the prosecutor will ask for an explanation:
“Why not follow the original budget process?”
- 📌 Lawyer's counterattack:Submit evidence of "administrative practice" or "urgent circumstances" (e.g., typhoon damage repairs require immediate funding)
Technique 3: Inducing witnesses to make unfavorable statements
When interviewing other civil servants, ask:
“How does your organization usually reimburse such expenses?”(Creating the impression of "abnormal write-offs")
- 📌 Lawyer's counterattack:Help the witnesses simulate interrogation in advance (note! Do not incite perjury),Article 181 of the Criminal Procedure LawAdvocate for a witness's right to refuse to testify
Techniques 4-6 (Attorney-Client Privilege Only)...
The rest of the prosecutor's offensive and defensive tactics involve specific case strategies, please immediatelyBook a confidential consultation
IV. Successful Case: How Lawyer Li Used the Large Reservoir Theory to Achieve a Not Guilty Verdict
Case Background:A county government official was accused of accepting 1.5 million yuan in kickbacks from manufacturers.Article 4, Paragraph 1, Clause 5 of the Anti-Corruption Ordinance"Accepting bribes while violating official duties" (minimum sentence: 10 years or more)
7 key actions taken by the legal team:
- Funds flowing to reconstruction:Use financial software to visualize fragmented cash flows (cash, remittances, gift certificates)
- Expert witness introduction:Entrust an accountant to issue a "Project Expenditure Reasonableness Appraisal Report"
- Administrative letter interpretation collection:Find out the cancellation license documents of similar cases in other agencies
- Media response:Prevent the client from being influenced by public opinion (Lawyer Li has assisted many political and business celebrities in handling similar crises)
- Sentencing Alternatives:Prepare a "social labor service plan" in advance to fight for probation
- Court offense and defense:When the prosecutor asked, "Why use this manufacturer?", he immediately brought up three government joint supply contracts.
- Verdict:The court accepted the large reservoir theory and sentenced him to six months in prison (commutable to a fine) under Article 342 of the Criminal Code for breach of trust.
💡 The key to winning this case:
We found that the prosecutor did not calculate the "820,000 yuan that the client paid out of his own pocket".Large Reservoir TheoryProve that "the overall revenue and expenditure is negative" and completely dismantle the subjective elements of "embezzlement"!
5. Golden Action Checklist for 72 Hours After Being Searched
If prosecutors and investigators have arrived at your office or residence with a search warrant, please proceed in the following order:
Phase 1: On-site response (0-6 hours)
- Request for a search warrant (to confirm the cause, scope, and time)
- Contact a lawyer immediately (according toArticle 150 of the Criminal Procedure Law)
- Take photos of the seized items list and sign it to prevent tampering.
Phase 2: Evidence Preservation (6-24 hours)
- Back up "unseized" emails and meeting minutes
- Apply for a "copy of official documents" from the relevant authorities (proving the payment decision procedure)
- Contact "potentially useful witnesses" but do not instruct them to commit perjury
Phase 3: Legal Offense and Defense (24-72 Hours)
- The lawyers reviewed the "Prosecution's Request for Detention" and formulated an appeal strategy
- Prepare preliminary evidence for the "Big Reservoir Theory" and submit a written statement to the prosecutor
- Assess whether to proactively apply for "precautionary exit restriction" (to avoid surprise border control)
⏰ The longer you delay, the worse it will be for you!
Start legal defense immediately► 02-77093611
About the author | Fidelity Legal Attorney Li Yusheng
📌 Current position:Host attorney at Fidelity Law Firm / Guest legal commentator on political commentary programs
📌 Areas of expertise:Defense of civil servants in corruption cases, political donation cases, and acquittal of crimes related to profiteering
📌 Practice philosophy:"While prosecutors scrutinize every financial transaction under a microscope, we use our expertise to show the court the full picture."
Final reminder: Corruption cases have1-year golden defense periodThe average time from interview to prosecution is only 10 months. Call Fidelity Legal's 24-hour hotline now. 02-77093611, make an appointment for consultation on [Survival Strategies for Corruption Cases].
⚖️ Fidelity Law Firm | 20 Years of Expertise in Corruption, Profiteering, Bribery, and Bribery Defense | Free Preliminary Case Analysis
📞 24-hour Line: @fdlaw
📍 17th Floor, No. 180, Section 2, Dunhua South Road, Da'an District, Taipei City
Click now 👉 Make an appointment for a lawyer consultation 👈 Let professional lawyers help you protect your life!
# Corruption # Anti-Corruption Ordinance # Public servant crime # Lawyers specializing in corruption cases # Crime of seeking profit # Crime of accepting bribes # Crime of offering bribes
Fuda Law Firm
Line：https://line.me/ti/p/@fdlaw
Tel:0277093611
Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/fudalawyer
website:https://fdlaw.com.tw/
e-mail:info@fdlaw.com.tw