Telephone
02-77093611
Line
@fdlaw
address
17th Floor, No. 180, Section 2, Dunhua South Road, Da'an District, Taipei City
This article provides a quick summary of key points.
- The amount of compensation must be supported by evidence:A trademark infringement claim is not a simple demand; it typically requires providing evidence of sales, profits, licensing fees, or damages.
- The law has different calculation methods:Claims can be made based on the rights holder's damages, the infringer's interests, reasonable royalties, or statutory damages.
- The scale of counterfeiting will affect strategy:Large-scale sales, cross-platform sales, importing counterfeit goods, or long-term infringement usually require a more comprehensive compensation plan.
- The person being sued should also check the amount:If a large claim is received, the evidence, sales volume, trademark usage, and compensation calculation should be examined to determine if they are reasonable.
In trademark infringement cases, the amount of damages is of great concern to the trademark owner. According to the relevant provisions of the Trademark Law and judicial practice experience, the request and calculation of damages mainly depend on the nature and scope of the infringement and the actual impact on the right holder. The following are the core methods and related considerations for calculating damages:
How damages are calculated
The Trademark Law provides the following main calculation methods, and the right holder can choose the most advantageous plan:
- Actual amount of damages
Direct economic losses suffered by rights holders due to infringement, including reduced sales, damage to goodwill, etc. For example, if a brand's sales volume decreases or its market share is diluted due to infringement, the corresponding amount can be calculated. - Benefits gained by the infringer
The amount of compensation shall be based on the illegal gains obtained by the infringer due to trademark infringement. The court will make calculations based on the number of products sold by the infringer, profit margin and other data, and require it to return its illegal gains. - License multiple
If it is difficult to prove actual losses or profits from infringement, the rights holder may request compensation based on the trademark licensing rate under normal market conditions, and may request a certain multiple (usually 1 to 3 times). - Statutory compensation amount
When the above methods cannot be calculated or proven, the court may award statutory compensation at the request of the right holder, with the upper limit of the amount generally being NT$5 million (in accordance with Article 97 of the Trademark Law).
importance of evidence
The amount of damages depends on the sufficiency of the evidence. Rights holders should collect relevant information as soon as possible, including but not limited to:
- Market prices and sales data of infringing goods;
- Historical information on trademark authorization or market conditions of similar authorizations;
- Invoices, contracts, etc. related to the infringer's transactions.
In addition, if the rights holder can prove that the infringement is malicious (such as continued infringement, counterfeiting of famous brands, etc.), the court may award a higher amount of compensation to achieve a punitive effect.
Difficulties and Strategies in Practical Operations
- Determine the scope of infringement
In many cases, the infringer may conceal the actual sales volume, and the rights holder needs to apply for a court order to obtain the infringer's financial information to accurately assess the scope of the damage. - Possibility of reconciliation between the parties
In order to avoid the waste of time and money caused by long-term litigation, many trademark infringement cases choose to settle during the litigation process. The settlement amount is usually between the infringer’s expected gains and the rights holder’s estimated losses. - Special considerations in international infringement cases
In cases involving cross-border trademark infringement, rights holders need to make requests based on the legal and economic standards of different regions and consider the actual implementation of law enforcement in each region.
Conclusion
Claims for damages in trademark infringement cases need to be supported by legal provisions and evidence, and the rights holder needs to choose the most advantageous calculation method based on the specific circumstances of the case. At the same time, professional lawyers should be hired to assist in the process to ensure the integrity of the evidence and the legality of the requested amount, so as to obtain the highest compensation amount and effectively curb the occurrence of infringement.
Further reading:What should I do if a trademark infringement occurs? Legal measures that can be taken.
Further reading:What are business secrets? Three major legal requirements for business secrets.
Further reading:What should I do if an employee takes away company confidential information? Relevant provisions of the Trade Secrets Act.
A Shield Protecting the Value of Innovation: Fidelity's Intellectual Property Law Team
Fuda Law Firm, composed of a team of lawyers, patent attorneys and patent engineering teams who specialize in patents and trademarks. They specialize in the field of intellectual property law. The team lawyer members all have rich practical experience and long-term experience in serving listed companies and small and medium-sized enterprises, and can provide assistance. . If you have any needs, you can contact our firm at any time.
Fuda Law Firm
Line：https://line.me/ti/p/@fdlaw
Tel:0277093611
Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/fudalawyer
website:https://fdlaw.com.tw/
Intellectual property rights website:https://fdlaw.com.tw/ip
e-mail:info@fdlaw.com.tw
Frequently Asked Questions
How is the amount of damages for trademark infringement calculated?
Trademark infringement damages may be calculated based on the actual damages suffered by the rights holder, the infringer's profits, reasonable royalties, or methods stipulated by law. The evidence and methods of assertion required vary from case to case.
Can one claim high damages for trademark infringement?
A higher amount can be claimed, but it still needs to be supported by evidence, such as the quantity of infringing goods, sales amount, profits, brand damage, licensing fees, or circumstances of infringement.
What should you do if you receive a trademark infringement claim?
It is recommended to first confirm whether there is actual infringement, whether the quantity of goods and sales amount are correct, and whether the scope of the other party's trademark rights is valid, and then have a lawyer assess negotiation, defense, or litigation strategies.
Further Reading on Trademark Infringement and Brand Protection
If you are dealing with company, responsible persons, contracts, financial transactions, investigative, or litigation risks, it is recommended that you first organize the facts, documents, and potential legal proceedings together, rather than relying on a single keyword. The following content can help you explore related topics further and quickly determine your next steps.
Intellectual Property, Trademark Infringement and Brand Protection
Trade secrets and information security
How to determine similar trademarks
Trademark Infringement Damages
Should a warning letter be sent first if a trademark is found to be counterfeited?
Not necessarily. If the other party may destroy evidence or ship large quantities of goods, you should first assess evidence collection, notarized purchase, platform reporting, customs or civil and criminal proceedings before deciding whether to send a letter.
How to determine similar trademarks?
Typically, a comprehensive assessment is taken into account appearance, pronunciation, concept, product or service category, likelihood of consumer confusion, and actual usage.
What remedies can be sought for trademark infringement?
This may include removing the infringement, preventing the infringement, compensating for damages, destroying infringing items, publishing judgments or criminal liability, and will be assessed based on the evidence and the circumstances of the case.
If you need legal assistance to determine the next step, you can first organize the above documents and timeline, and then contact Fidelity Law Firm for assistance in assessing the direction of the process. Contact Fidelity Law Firm